So… When Do You Jump In On 11ac? Like Really?

The blogosphere is awash with speculation on how 802.11ac is going to transform the way we use wireless, and what the new WLAN will do for productivity. It’s great stuff, and needs to be talked up. We see early releases of actual 11ac draft product, great whitepapers from the Big Guns, and even better blogs on 11ac from some of the best wireless minds in the industry. If you’re not getting a working knowledge of 11ac by now, it’s not for lack of available information.

Never has WiFi been more complex, more promising, and more confusing. I don’t mean technically confusing; if you’re a wireless professional, you’ll wrap  your head around the technical side of 802.11ac. Some of my own frequent talking points on 11ac:

  • yeah, the standard promises up to 6.9 Gbps data rates. But 11n also promises up to 600, and we’ll never see it. Real initial 11ac offerings are still going to be measured at speeds slightly better or even the same as 11n’s best
  • the 5 GHz-only thing is great for everyone, and will help de-congest the ugly 2.4 GHz band
  • early client devices have to be watched- a 3×3 11ac Macbook pro will run circles around a TP-Link 1×1 USB adapter, but they both “are” 11ac. Real client throughputs on 11ac are going to be all over the place
  • the Wave 1/Wave 2 thing is really gonna be a weird one for people who have to plan when to jump in, and killer features like Multi-User-MIMO don’t materialize until the second wave
  • Regardless of how 11ac plays out in the trenches, Ethernet needs to start being more aggressively marginalized. Limited budgets can’t support competing access technologies, and mobility will become more of  trump factor when dollars get spent

This brings me back to my question- When do different organizations start migrating to 11ac? This is the part that is confusing.

Talking with Cisco and Aerohive back a few months, the topic of life-cycle came up in relation to 11ac. If you have old gear and have to upgrade, first-wave 11ac might make sense in that you can skip right past 11n. But if you are like me, and have a fairly recent 11n build-out and no real performance pain points, it’s just not as easy of a paradigm. Stop-gaps like Cisco’s 3600 AP 11ac radio module help bridge the technological generation gap between 11n and 11ac deployments, but at an estimated $500 a pop list price, may not be worth the cost. Upgrading twice to 11ac for the first and second waves is a thorny proposition.

For small environments, lesser AP counts do remove some of the complication. But when you have hundreds or thousands of access points, you can’t help but scratch your head when it comes to thoughts of moving to 11ac.

Personally, I am hoping to see a first-wave AP emerge that is somehow upgradeable to a full-fledged second-waver. But I’m also aware of the complexity of putting these things together, and building a 4×4 AP that can “expand” to the likes of 8 streams isn’t likely. Also, close monitoring of client device types in use (we’re a huge BYOD environment) will be a must while we watch how new 11ac devices trickle in.

For now then, I guess it’s still a game of watching and waiting. Hopefully soon we’ll see announcements from the WLAN makers that somehow help those of us driving really big WLANs to see a sensible path forward that doesn’t include a “buy THIS 11ac AP today, then buy THAT 11ac next year” recommendation.

6 thoughts on “So… When Do You Jump In On 11ac? Like Really?

  1. Keith R. Parsons

    I really don’t think there will be a ‘software upgrade’ from Wave 1 to Wave 2 equipment. So if you jump on the .11ac bandwagon early, you’ll be locking in the Wave 2 upgrade. But… if you really need the .11ac today, and have clients that need it… then perhaps it will be useful.

    I just see this Wave 1 gear as a chance for vendor marketing and sales people to get hyped about something.

    I’ve always told my customers to design your WLAN today to support tomorrow’s clients, not yesterday’s clients. But with where we are right now, .11ac clients are next week’s clients, not even available tomorrow…

    Keith

    Reply
  2. Gregor Vučajnk (@GregorVucajnk)

    The first wave of .11 ac will be fantastic and to everyone’s benefit. Everybody has to make opportunity of it!
    .
    .
    .
    .
    .
    The best thing about the 1st gen of the .11 ac line is that it’ll bring the cost of the .11n flagship products down. The new .ac will be priced, imho, as the .11n flagship devices are now.

    :).

    Reply
  3. Dani (@DaniF15)

    For my opinion there is no reason to upgrade until MU-MIMO will come out,I think that when it will come out we will see more sophisticated antennas comes along with it ,and it will take some time. also i would not expect any Atheros based AP’s (Ruckus/Arube etc) to come out with 11ac in the coming year even though they suggest they will…Great post!

    Reply
  4. Pingback: So- How Much Interference And How Many Wires Would You Like With Your 802.11ac? | wirednot

  5. Pingback: So… When Do You Jump In On 11ac? Like Really?

  6. Pingback: With 11ac, The WLAN Industry Owes Customers A New Kind Of Network Switch | wirednot

Tell me what YOU think.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s